Ristorante Caffe' Gustami is a restaurant in Jewellery Quarter, Birmingham. Rated 4.8 stars from 620 Google reviews. Known for authentic homemade pasta & pizza and family-run warmth and hospitality. Best for authentic italian dinner and celebrations. Price range: £10–20.
Rankings updated August 2026
Ristorante Caffe' Gustami
| Rating | 4.8★ |
| Reviews | 620 |
| Best for | Authentic Italian dinner |
Better value than the Jewellery Quarter average
Around £15 a head, below the £30 typical for Jewellery Quarter and rated higher than the area at 4.8★ against 4.7★. Based on the 12 Jewellery Quarter venues we hold Google pricing for.
Quick Verdict
A hidden gem delivering authentic Italian cooking and genuine hospitality in an intimate, unpretentious setting at remarkable value.
You want authentic Italian cooking and genuine hospitality without pretence or inflated prices.
About Ristorante Caffe' Gustami
Ristorante Caffe' Gustami is a family-run Italian restaurant tucked into the Jewellery Quarter, where authenticity and warmth define the experience. The kitchen delivers homemade pasta, wood-fired pizza with crispy bases, and daily specials rooted in genuine Italian technique—reviewers consistently note the freshness of ingredients and the care evident in every dish. Owner Silvio and his daughter work the room with genuine hospitality, taking time to explain specials and make guests feel like they're dining in a trattoria rather than a restaurant. The wine list is thoughtfully curated, and the tiramisu and panna cotta are standout desserts. At £10–20 per head, the value proposition is exceptional: three courses, wine, and coffee for under £80 is routine here. The intimate, unpretentious setting—described as cosy and warm—suits both casual dinners and celebrations equally well. Outdoor terrace seating adds to the appeal.
What Stands Out
Authentic homemade pasta & pizza
Reviewers consistently praise freshly-prepared homemade pasta, wood-fired pizza with crispy bases, and ingredients that taste as if transported from Italy itself.
Family-run warmth and hospitality
Owner Silvio and his daughter create a welcoming atmosphere where staff explain specials, remember guests, and make diners feel like family across multiple visits.
Exceptional value
Three courses, wine, and coffee routinely total under £80; reviewers highlight 'fantastic prices' and 'incredible value' for the quality delivered.
Practical Information
Contact
Frequently Asked Questions about Ristorante Caffe' Gustami
Yes. Reviewers note the welcoming, friendly staff and authentic food make it ideal for solo diners. The casual, family-run atmosphere means you won't feel out of place dining alone.
Homemade pasta (especially ravioli and tortellini), wood-fired pizza, and the tiramisu are consistently highlighted. The daily specials board is also worth exploring—staff explain each one.
Expect £10–20 per head. Three courses with wine and coffee typically comes to under £80 for two. Reviewers praise the value relative to quality.
Yes. An outdoor terrace is available, described as having great ambience and a relaxed, hospitable vibe where staff encourage lingering.
Yes. Reviewers mention vegetarian options including a vegan lasagne, and staff are attentive to dietary needs.
Booking is recommended. The restaurant is small and intimate, and reviewers note it fills up—a table reservation ensures you won't be turned away.
Also in Jewellery Quarter
View all21 venues changed rank in Jewellery Quarter in the latest ranking → See full zone ranking
How We Rank Venues
Rankings are recalculated monthly from live Google Business Profile data. Our Hot Score weighs review velocity (new text reviews), baseline rating, and Google Business Profile completeness. No editorial picks, no paid placements — just what the data says this month.
How our monthly rankings work